The short version
- POM (acetal, Delrin) when the part has to stay the size you drew it, in normal humidity, and slide against metal or another plastic. It machines cleanly and holds tolerance.
- Nylon (PA6 cast, PA66) when the part takes impact, runs dry against steel, or works in abrasive dust. It is tougher than POM and wears better under shock, but it absorbs water and moves.
- UHMWPE when the surface is large, the load is spread over an area, and sliding friction or slurry abrasion is the dominant wear mode. It is the slickest and the most abrasion-resistant of the three, and the least stiff.
The rest of this page is the reasoning behind those three lines, and the cases where the rule of thumb is wrong.
A like-for-like comparison
| Property | POM-C | Nylon PA6 (cast) | UHMWPE |
|---|---|---|---|
| Density | 1.41 g/cm³ | 1.15 g/cm³ | 0.94 g/cm³ |
| Water absorption, 24 h | 0.2 % | 1.5–2.5 % | < 0.01 % |
| Water absorption, saturation | ~0.8 % | 6–7 % | < 0.01 % |
| Tensile strength | 65–70 MPa | 80 MPa dry, 55 MPa conditioned | 20–25 MPa |
| Tensile modulus | 2.8–3.1 GPa | 3.0 GPa dry, 1.2 GPa conditioned | 0.7–0.9 GPa |
| Continuous service temperature | 90–100 °C | 90–105 °C | 80 °C, with creep above 60 °C |
| Coefficient of friction vs steel | 0.15–0.35 | 0.15–0.30 | 0.10–0.20 |
| Abrasion resistance, sliding | Good | Very good | Best |
| Impact strength | Moderate, brittle notch | High | High, but low stiffness |
| Dimensional stability | Excellent | Poor in humidity | Excellent, poor under load |
| Machining | Excellent | Good, gummy when warm | Fair, needs sharp tools |
Values are typical for unfilled grades and vary by supplier and by thickness. A glass-filled or MoS₂-filled grade moves each column, usually toward stiffness and away from impact.
Moisture is the deciding factor more often than wear
Nylon’s water absorption is the single most common reason a part that worked in the workshop fails in service. PA6 cast absorbs up to 6–7 % of its own weight at saturation, and that shows up as roughly 0.5–1.5 % linear growth, depending on wall thickness and grade.
Put a number on it: a 100 mm nylon bushing can grow close to 1 mm across the diameter between a dry warehouse in winter and a humid plant in summer. If the bore was machined to H7 with 0.03 mm clearance, that clearance is gone, and the part seizes.
There are three ways to handle it, in order of preference:
- Condition the material before machining. Boil or humidity-condition the stock to near its service moisture content, then machine. The part then moves less after installation.
- Design clearance for wet growth. Allow for the saturated dimension, not the dry one, and state the moisture condition on the drawing.
- Use POM instead when the part is a precision fit and the environment is uncontrolled.
POM absorbs about a tenth as much and reaches its equilibrium in days rather than months. UHMWPE absorbs essentially nothing, which is why it is used for parts that sit in water, slurry or washdown.
Abrasion: three different mechanisms
“Abrasion resistant” means different things depending on what is rubbing what.
Slurry and bulk abrasive — sand, ore, cement, wet concrete. UHMWPE wins clearly. Its very low friction stops particles from bedding into the surface, and its toughness absorbs the impact of individual grains. A POM chute liner in this service polishes and then wears through; the UHMWPE one lasts several times longer.
Dry sliding against steel — guide rails, cam followers, wear pads. UHMWPE has the lowest friction; POM has the best combination of friction, stiffness and creep resistance for a loaded pad. Nylon runs slightly hotter because it is softer and has a higher friction coefficient when dry.
Impact plus abrasion — hammer mill liners, hopper edges, discharge lips. Nylon’s higher impact strength and better recovery make it the choice over POM, which chips at a sharp edge under repeated shock. UHMWPE also works here if the part can be supported, because it is too flexible to carry load on its own.
The trap is specifying by the word “abrasion” alone. A part that fails by chipping is an impact problem; a part that fails by losing thickness uniformly is a sliding-wear problem; a part that fails by grooving is a particle-embedding problem. Each points at a different material.
Creep: the one UHMWPE cannot fix
UHMWPE has a low modulus and creeps under sustained load, especially above 60 °C. A UHMWPE pad under a constant 5 MPa load at 50 °C will thin over months, and a UHMWPE bushing under a radial load will ovalise.
POM is the most dimensionally stable of the three under sustained load, followed by nylon, with UHMWPE a distant third. So the usual engineering compromise is a UHMWPE wear surface on a POM or metal backing — the slick face takes the abrasion, the stiff part takes the load.
Nylon sits between them: better creep resistance than UHMWPE, worse than POM, and its creep accelerates as it absorbs moisture and softens.
Machining and tolerance
All three machine on ordinary CNC equipment, but not identically.
- POM cuts dry with sharp, polished tools, produces a clean chip and holds ±0.02 mm on a 50 mm bore without drama. It is the easiest of the three to hold a tolerance on.
- Nylon cuts well when dry and cool, but gummy chips and heat build-up cause poor finish and oversize bores if the feed is rushed. Cast PA6 is better than extruded for thick sections because it has less internal stress.
- UHMWPE is soft and springy: it deflects away from the tool, so bores come out undersize and need a finishing pass, and thin walls deform in the chuck. Clamping pressure alone can put a part out of tolerance permanently.
A practical consequence: when a drawing carries ±0.05 mm or tighter on a bore, and no material is specified, the default should be POM. Nylon and UHMWPE can hold it, but only with the right stock condition and a slower cycle, which shows up in the price.
Temperature
All three top out around 90–105 °C continuous, which is lower than most buyers expect.
| Service | POM | Nylon | UHMWPE |
|---|---|---|---|
| Continuous, air | 90–100 °C | 90–105 °C | 80 °C |
| Short excursion | 140 °C | 150–180 °C | 90 °C |
| Limitation | Formaldehyde odour, embrittlement over time | Property loss as moisture leaves | Softening and creep; brittles below −40 °C |
Above these ranges the answer is a different material family — PEEK to 250 °C, PTFE to 260 °C, or a thermoset. See the PTFE vs PEEK vs POM comparison for where that boundary sits.
Which one for which part
| Part | Usual choice | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Conveyor wear strip | UHMWPE | Low friction, no moisture movement, long life on a supported surface |
| Chain guide rail | UHMWPE | Sliding contact with low load per unit area |
| Precision bushing, dry | POM | Holds bore tolerance, low moisture uptake |
| Flange bushing under shock | Nylon | Absorbs impact that would crack POM |
| Gear, light duty | POM | Stiffness and fatigue resistance; nylon is used where noise matters more |
| Sprocket | POM or nylon | POM for accuracy, nylon for shock loads |
| Roller, washdown | UHMWPE | Zero water absorption, no swelling |
| Hammer mill liner | Nylon | Impact plus abrasion |
| Chute liner | UHMWPE | Slurry abrasion |
| Part in a humid, uncontrolled plant | POM | The only one of the three that stays put |
Where the rule of thumb breaks
Three cases where the standard advice is wrong:
Food and medical contact. Standard POM and nylon grades are not food approved. Both are available in compliant grades, but the grade, not the polymer, is what carries the certificate — so specify it on the drawing rather than assuming.
Glass-filled grades. Adding 20–30 % glass fibre raises stiffness and lowers creep, but it also raises friction against steel, wears the mating surface, and makes the part more notch-sensitive. A GF nylon is not automatically better than an unfilled one for a wear part.
Very large parts. Water absorption and internal stress both scale with section thickness. A 200 mm diameter cast nylon part behaves differently from a 40 mm one, and the machining allowance has to account for it.
Getting it right the first time
The information that decides the material is rarely on the drawing. Send us the drawing plus four facts and the recommendation is straightforward:
- Ambient and operating temperature, including start-up and cleaning cycles
- Whether the part runs dry, in water, in slurry, or with grease
- The load and whether it is continuous or intermittent
- What the part runs against — steel, stainless, aluminium, or another plastic
We machine all three materials, so the recommendation is not biased toward one of them.
Related reading
- PTFE vs PEEK vs POM — the high-temperature and chemical end of the same question
- Material selection guide — the full list of polymers we machine, by property
- POM machining — grades, design rules and tolerances for acetal parts
- UHMWPE wear strip — profiles, thickness selection and thermal expansion
- Nylon flange bushing — the bushing form, with the moisture allowance built in